Saturday, May 25, 2024

How To Give Interview Feedback To Hr

Don't Miss

Sample Three Response To A Rejection Email After An Interview

How to Give Candidate Feedback After an Interview
Dear Mr Jason,I just received your email informing me that I've been turned down for the Marketing Associate position. While I was disappointed to find out, I hope you'll keep a copy of my resume for future opportunities in your company.  I want to thank you for considering me for the position. If you have the time, I would like some feedback on my interview and resume. Thank you again,Jack Osato.

Dont Hold It Off Or Procrastinate

Waiting for news, good or bad is always nerve-wracking. Leaving a candidate hanging on is bad practice and is only going to invite antagonism. Respond quickly and professionally to all enquiries and let your candidates know quickly if they have been unsuccessful. This will allow them to continue with their job search or even accept other offers which may be on the table. You would expect a quick decision on a job offer, and so the same courtesy must be extended to your candidate. Any procrastination will just increase the likelihood of the all-important feedback being neglected leading to the impending derogatory Glassdoor review.

How To Help Your Hiring Team Share Interview Feedback Efficiently

With post-interview communication, it doesnt only matter what you say, but also how you share your feedback with your team members. Timely, well-organized and easily accessible feedback helps make better hiring decisions faster.

Heres how to build systems and scores to document interview feedback for hiring managers and the whole hiring team consistently throughout your recruiting process:

Read Also: How To Prepare For A Marketing Interview

Praise And Be Positive

Feedback shouldnt only be used as a tool to inform a candidate where they have fallen short. They need to know where they have performed well in order for them to continue to do so. Among your advice for improvement, there needs to be a balance. Try to pick out at least one area where they have excelled and let them know why you were impressed.

What To Include In Your Follow

How to document interview feedback: Hiring manager and team

It’s important to be disciplined when sending your follow-up email. Follow this guide for a simple, professional message that gives you the best chance of receiving a response.

Subject line

There is no need to spend hours deliberating over a snappy subject line. The most effective approach that is likely to get your message opened quickly, is to respond to the most recent email between you and the interviewer or HR manager. If this isn’t possible simply include your name, the date and time of the interview.

As a guide, follow this format:

John Smith – Re: Interview on Tuesday at 4pm


If you’re on first-name terms with the person you’re contacting – you may have exchanged multiple emails and spoken face to face by this point, then it is fine to open your follow-up email by using their first name. If not, or if you’re unsure, stick with their title and surname .

Body text

Keep it simple. Presumably, the main reason you’re emailing is for a progress update – the interviewer will know this before they’ve even opened your message. Be polite but direct:

  • Thank them for their time in the interview.
  • Explain that you’re following up on your interview – remember to be specific about the job, mentioning the job title and interview date.
  • Restate your interest in the position and say you’re keen to hear about next steps.
  • Ask for a progress update, explaining that any information they can provide would be greatly appreciated.

Signing off

Final checks

Also Check: What Is An Exit Interview For A Job

The Importance Of Interview Feedback

Feedback after the interview is a crucial aspect of the hiring process. Giving candidate feedback helps in building the companys reputation. A candidate is likely to consider the company the next time if provided with constructive feedback. Some of the importance of interview feedback is discussed below.

  • Drives better candidate experience: When candidates are given constructive interview feedback, the companys reputation increases.
  • Candidates feel they are in the loop: Giving feedback also helps them know that the company cares. This way, candidates feel that they are in the loop.
  • Keeps the candidates updated: Interview feedback lets the candidates know where they stand in the pool of candidates and what they should improve on for the next round of interviews.
  • Teaches the interviewees how to give feedback: Give a template to the interview panel a template of interview feedback. Using templates can help in building up feedback information quickly and easily.

Why Did You Decide To Work At This Company

This question gives an interviewer a chance to do two self-serving things: talk about themselves and perform a no-holds-barred sales pitch on the company.

For promising candidates, the sales opportunity is welcomed. And most people love any excuse to talk about themselves.

How It Helps You

This gives you insight into what motivates your future colleague or manager, as well as what the company offers its employees. If those all line up with what you’re looking for in a job, you’ve got yourself a good fit.

Recommended Reading: How To Nail Amazon Interview

How To Give Your Candidate Interview Feedback

July 6, 2020 | Interviewing

While it is never fun for a candidate to receive word that they did not get the job, there is one thing that makes the pill a little easier to swallow: genuine interview feedback. Oftentimes, the most frustrating part of rejection is the lingering question of why?, especially if the candidate had an interview that generally went well.

Giving feedback after an interview takes precious time out of your already-busy day, but it is more than just a show of kindness to candidates who went to the effort to prepare for interviews while navigating through your hiring funnel it can actually help strengthen your hiring process. Here, we will explain the value of giving interview feedback and outline some best practices for doing it effectively.

Is There A Dress Code I Should Abide By

Interview Feedback | Whether we should give feedback to candidates #hr #interview #readytogetupdate

Dress code can be a touchy subject in interviews you don’t want to reveal that you have deal-breakers so early into a hiring process. But, it is an important aspect of the job for many professionals.

If you want to get an idea of the company’s dress code without suggesting it’s a big deal to you, simply ask HR what you’re expected to wear on your first day. It’s a harmless question that gives you the information you need at the same time.

Also Check: What Questions Should I Ask During An Interview

Cover The Whole Hiring Process

Feedback shouldnt just come from the hiring manager. To provide good-quality feedback after interview, its important to tap into the whole interview and recruiting process to gain a representative overview of the candidates performance.

This is especially true when the candidate experience involves many steps, such as questionnaires, video interviews, first and second round in-person interviews and skill tests.

Focus On Professional Attributes Not Personal Impressions


She has strong technical knowledge and would be a very desirable candidate for any business in this industry. If appointed, we should discuss her career goals to make sure she is engaged and challenged in the role.

She could do the job, but seemed bored and a little aloof during our chat. I wonder if she really wants this job.

Read Also: How To Answer Tell Me About Yourself Med School Interview

Template For Job Interview Feedback Email To Candidates

Subject line: Looking for interview feedback

Dear ,

I am reaching out to you to ask you for a feedback about interview process.

As candidate experience is extremely important to us, your feedback would be of a great value for us. This is a few question survey that won’t take more than few minutes.

Here is the to the survey.

Thank you in advance,

Need more HR and recruiting templates like this candidate interview invitation email? Check templates for Human Resources and templates for Recruiters.

Do you use a modern recruitment software? If not, you’re missing out. See how your life can be easier. Start your free 14-day TalentLyft trial.


The Pivotal Role Of Interview Feedback

Ide Mock Interview Evaluation Form, Paling Populer!

This quote by Mary Jackson, writing in HR Magazine, sums it up: Feedback is powerful. Anyone who takes the time to attend an interview is entitled to it. This is why feedback is so important for your hiring process and reputation, overall.

Imagine if your preferred candidate doesnt accept the job offer. If you havent given helpful and constructive feedback to the other candidates who were a near miss , you might lose the chance to employ them, too!

Read Also: What Makes You A Good Leader Interview Answer

Review The Job Description In Relation To The Candidate’s Qualifications

The job description highlights the job responsibilities and skills that a candidate should have to qualify for the role. Because of this, it’s a great tool to reference when completing your interview feedback. Compare and contrast the job description to a candidate’s qualifications and interview experience to aid your decision-making.

How Do You Write An Interview Feedback Example

This example can give you a better understanding regarding how to structure your own evaluation:

From the start, Amanda appeared slightly shy or reserved, but when we started the interview, she showed herself to be an expressive, well-read professional.Throughout our meeting, she displayed extensive knowledge of marketing and advertising, as highlighted by her past roles. She’s also finished extensive research on social media advertising analytics and gave me detailed examples of how a business can leverage data to make major changes to their marketing and advertising efforts.

In general, I think Amanda is a fantastic candidate for the position of marketing manager. She’s experienced, she’s enthusiastic, and she’s a great multitasker. I believe she could provide valuable insights into our marketing strategy.I suggest we schedule Amanda for a group interview and start discussing salary expectations.

Also Check: How To Prepare For A Video Recorded Interview

What To Include In Interview Feedback

Review this list to determine what you should include when writing interview feedback:

  • First impressions of the candidate: This could include initial assessments about their character or personality and how your impression changed or stayed the same throughout the interview.

  • Insights into both interpersonal and technical skills: When writing interview feedback, it’s important that you equally present a candidate’s interpersonal and technical skills so members of your team can properly evaluate their potential as an employee. For instance, if you say a candidate has excellent verbal communication, active listening and adaptability skills, make sure you also mention their proficiency with word processing software, project management experience and public speaking skills.

  • Summary of the interview experience: You should include a summary that outlines how the interview went and how a candidate conducted themselves. This helps the hiring team when reviewing interview feedback for multiple candidate’s at once.

  • Clear suggestions moving forward: Directly following the summary, provide your opinion on whether you think a candidate should continue through the hiring process or receive a job offer. You also need to briefly explain your decision.

Related: What Are Interview Guides?

Position The Feedback In Terms Of Results And Consequences

What to Know About Getting Job Interview Feedback from an Employer

Hiring managers are results-oriented. They care about the end-game: getting the best candidate in an efficient way. A great way to get them to listen to and appreciate your feedback is to frame it in terms of the results theyll see.

John Vlastelica, founder of Recruiting Toolbox, recommends that recruiters offer hiring managers advice with this question:

Would you want me to tell you what managers who fill roles 10 days faster do differently?

If Im not framing so that the outcome sounds like it has a positive impact on speed and quality, he says, theyre probably not going to do it. By focusing on the potential results of your feedback, youre also emphasizing that its nothing personalyoure just offering practical advice thats in their interest.

Recommended Reading: How To Prepare For Data Structures And Algorithms Interview

Give Concise Actionable Feedback

Your feedback is only useful if the candidate or hiring manager can act on it in the future, so make sure what youre offering is instructive and concrete. Steer away from vague evaluations and try to give specific examples of when the candidate showed particular strengths and weaknesses.

If youre feeding back to a candidate, keep the feedback brief and tightly focused. After all, the document is only one companys verdict and will be one of several factors influencing their overall jobseeking strategy.

Write Notes On The Interview Question Sheet

During and after a candidate interview, take notes to gather your initial thoughts about them and their ability to contribute to the company. Use an interview question sheet to take notes or create a scoring chart to document their strengths and weaknesses. Good notes can help you compare each candidate and provide more accurate feedback to choose the best candidate for the company. You can take notes on things like:

  • The candidate’s interview style

  • The candidate’s views or goals

Read more:21 Tips for Interviewers

Read Also: How To Thank Interviewer After Interview

Comparing The Notes Against The Job Profile

Comparing the notes you have prepared with the job role and responsibilities helps ascertain if the candidate is the perfect fit for the role or not. Through comparison, you can easily know if the candidate can fulfill all the hiring teams job duties.

You must carefully go through the job description and use it as a reference to assess the candidate and figure out the applicants suitability for the organization.

Carefully overview the qualifications and use them to determine if they would be a good fit or if you need to find a better candidate. Put everything in your notes and give reasons for your decisions.

How To Ask For Feedback

Always Get/Give Interview Feedback, It Matters

Asking for feedback after an interview can be challenging, especially when you dont know what to say. Samuel Johns, a hiring manager at Resume Genius, says that when asking for feedback, phrasing is key. Say something like Since Im applying for similar jobs in this industry and want to work on my interview skills, I was wondering if you have any feedback for me. This wording makes it much more likely that the interviewer will provide feedback because they can see your focus is on self-improvement.

Also Check: How To Ace And Interview

How To Write A Response Email To A Rejection Email

Like other professional emails, writing a response to a job rejection email has certain elements that should be observed thoroughly.

  • Thank the Interviewers
  • Showing appreciation is the first stage of writing a reply to a rejection letter. When writing the thank you part of a rejection email, certain sections should be written in your email.

    The first part is to thank the hiring manager for letting you know of their decision to go with another candidate. This will not be pleasing to write, but for the reasons listed above, its best to get on with it.

    Secondly, thank the hiring manager for their time and consideration.

    Lastly, express your gratitude for an opportunity to learn about the company. This part of your email shouldnt be longer than a few sentences. Expressing your gratitude is a great way to start your response email.

    • Express your Disappointment and show continued interest

    Writing a reply to a rejection email and expressing disappointment helps to convey your genuine interest in the position.

    In your email responding to a rejection, it is crucial to write about your continued interest in the position and in working for the company. Expressing your interest confirms to the manager that youd like to be contacted for future opportunities.

    • Request for feedback

    When dealing with rejection emails, its essential to remember that the reason you werent selected may have nothing to do with your credentials. They may choose another candidate for reasons such as location.

    Automate The Process When Possible

    Set up automated notifications after each interview to remind interviewers they need to share their feedback. To help hiring teams share their evaluations and keep every comment organized, consider investing in effective software. Workable is an all-in-one recruiting platform that lets you share interview feedback with your hiring team in a safe and collaborative environment. Learn how to:

    Recommended Reading: How To Present Yourself In An Interview

    Do You Have Any Questions Or Concerns About My Qualifications

    This question shows that you’re not afraid of critical feedback in fact, you welcome it.

    Interviewers tend to make note of red flags to discuss with a colleague following the interview, whether it be something on your resume or something you said

    . This question gives them the green light to ask about any of the things that are holding them back from being 100% on board with hiring you.

    How It Helps You

    You get a chance to address concerns face-to-face without being too confrontational. This could be the difference between an offer and a rejection – or maybe even a higher opening offer.

    Take Extra Notes About Whether A Candidate Displayed Role Requirements

    #1 – HR Interview Q& A – Introduction Video

    It may be challenging trying to stay engaged in the session and taking notes concurrently. You may make better evaluations by focusing on capturing the necessary information. This can mean staying more alert when the person is demonstrating role requirements. Be it paying attention to what the candidate is saying or showing in terms of body language, you can take these additional notes, so you’re also more likely to remember the person and what transpired during the interview.

    Recommended Reading: What Makes A Great Interview

    The Importance Of Feedback

    While it might seem like a lot of work right now, giving feedback is not only good for your company, but youre also helping the candidate to understand where their strengths and weaknesses lie. Having said that, some employers have policies against giving feedback out of fear of inadvertently creating legal risk. Equally, not all candidates want to receive feedback, but for those that do its vital they receive the type of feedback that can help them grow and give them something to build on.

    Candidates need to understand how they can improve, says Laurie West, talent acquisition manager at Exchange Team. Peoples own ideas about how they think they are perceived and how they actually are perceived in interviews can differ greatly, and its all about closing that gap.

    However, I find that good feedback is rarely given, particularly in large companies. But with the right mind-set, you can give feedback that will really benefit the candidate going forward.

    Although you dont want to go as far as saying someone came to the interview dressed like a tramp or that they seemed a little lazy, honesty is always the best policy. But dont just tell them a bunch of cliched reasons with no real substance behind it, as there are real benefits when you provide a detailed assessment of an interviewees performance.

    Thanks to the internet, a lot more people have found out about the companys dubious approach, which is unlikely to put it on top of anyones dream places to work list.

    More articles

    Popular Articles