How To Conduct A Legal Working Interview
All too often employers are stuck in a situation with a new employee who has overemphasized or fibbed about his or her qualifications for a position. To better choose candidates, many professions use working interviews to test a job applicants knowledge, skills, and abilities prior to making an offer of employment. The interview consist of seeing how the applicant interacts with staff, clients, and patients and often involves participation in routine employment activities over several hours or days to evaluate the candidate. But are working interviews legal?
Of course, never rely on any interview procedure alone to evaluate an employee. Most employees are on their best behavior during the first 30 days of employment. A well-managed practice will have an employee handbook in place with probationary periods to evaluate newly hired employees over periods upwards of 90 days before providing benefits, such as sick days or even salary increases.
The Value Of A Working Interview
Rose is just one example of many employees who leave the workplace just within six months of stay in their first job. This is because theres a gap between the applicants job expecations and the actual work required. For this reason, companies lose about 30 to 50% of the newbies annual salary just to replace those who resigned early.
These pitfalls can be avoided by conducting a working interview.
The Temp Agency Loophole
The reason the temp agency loophole makes it legal to perform working interviews is that the candidates are actually employed by the temp agency when sourced in this way.
More specifically, the temp agency fulfills all of the new hire paperwork and employer obligationsfor you. Many employers forget this important fact.
It is when employers attempt to cut out the temp agency middleman that they end up vulnerable to a host of problems. These include:
- Not having coverage if the worker is injured while in your office
- HIPAA violations, and more.
Moreover, if you do not hire the worker and they become disgruntled, they now have leverage over you to file a complaint because you have not complied with the law.
You May Like: What To Wear For An Interview Women
During The Job Interview
You’ve done your research, you brought copies of your resume, and you’ve prepared responses for questions that might arise based on your resume. Now the time for the interview has come, and with that comes the oft-dreaded part of interviewing: the questions.
“Candidates get nervous about job interviews because there’s the potential they’ll be asked an open-ended question that will give the interviewer a secret view into who the candidate really is,” said Rich Milgram, founder and CEO of career network Nexxt. “But the real secret is that a lot of the time the interviewer doesn’t know what the right answer is either, or they’ll admit that there is no right answer, so just relax.”
Glassdoor recently compiled a list of the most asked questions to expect in an interview:
- What are your strengths?
- Tell me how you handled a difficult situation.
- Why should we hire you?
What To Expect During A Working Interview
All companies approach interviews differently. The same holds true for working interviews, which is why its important to ask questions.
If youre the hiring manager setting up a working interview, check with your recruiting team to understand the company’s guidelines around time commitment and compensation. Also, be aware of not sharing proprietary information or other competitive or protected data.
If youve been invited to a working interview, here are four things you can expect.
Youll be asked to do real work. Some prospective employers will give you a specific project. Others may ask you to use your skills to assist in a teammates project or another workstream. Regardless, the purpose of a working interview is to show your work.
- You might have to take a technical skill assessment. Depending on the role youre interviewing for, you may be asked to take a skills test. For example, if youre a software engineer, you may be asked to write some code. You might be asked to evaluate or improve upon someone elses code. Or, if youre a writer, you might be asked to draft a blog or copy.
Ive been a part of interviews where companies ask the candidate to take part in a take-home assessment or project. This is different from a working interview. This is a project that is simply used for sample purposes .
Read Also: Cfo Interview
What Questions To Ask Employees Returning To Work
Questions should cover topics such as how their health is currently and whether they are fit enough to return to work . whether they have sought medical advice if anything work-related contributed to your absence and if there are any workplace adjustments which could support with their return to work.
Tips For A Successful Interview
The impression you make on the interviewer often can outweigh your actual credentials. Your poise, attitude, basic social skills, and ability to communicate are evaluated along with your experience and education.
You and the interviewer must engage in a conversation – a mutual exchange of information and ideas. Only through such a dialogue can you both determine if you, the organization, and the job are well matched. Preparation is the key.
Be on time.This often means 10-15 minutes early. Interviewers often are ready before the appointment.
Know the interviewers name, its spelling, and pronunciation.Use it during the interview. If you dont know the name, call beforehand and ask the secretary. Also, note the secretarys name in case you have to call back. Secretaries can influence the hiring decision!
Have some questions of your own prepared in advance.There is nothing wrong with having a short list of questions and thoughts- it shows you have done your research and want to know more about the organization and the position.
Bring several copies of your resume.Also, bring a copy of your transcript. Carry your papers in an organized manner.
Have a reliable pen and a small note pad with you.But do not take notes during the interview. However, immediately afterward, write down as much as you can remember, including your impression of how well you did.
Greet the interviewer with a handshake and a smile.Remember to maintain eye contact .
You May Like: Interview Attire Women
Drawbacks Of The Working Interview
The working interview does have a few negatives. For one, it takes a longer time to set up and involves more people. Also, the job candidate will not swoop in and do the job as well or as quickly as an experienced employee would. Some will just perform poorly at the assigned tasks.
You may not want to pay job candidates for their time, but that’s the way a working interview must be done. Write them a check even if you may hire them for the position. The recommendation is to issue a check the day of the working interview. Itâs perfectly fine to hand it to them at the end of the day, once the interview is complete.
Since the job candidate is actually working at your company on that one day, they may become confused and believe that they already have the job, particularly since they will have to fill out some paperwork. You must make it clear to each interviewee that hiring decisions will be made after the interview process is complete. Finish all your working interviews and then make your decision. Do not hire anyone on the day of the interview to avoid confusion.
Additionally, because the job candidate was actually hired by your practice, they will be eligible to apply for unemployment benefits.
Begin With The General Questions You Prepared
The types of questions you ask play one of the most important roles in the hiring process. Its important to ask about the candidates interest in the position. Remember to vary your questions, between those of behavioral and situational questions.
You cant get to know the applicant with questions that evoke a simple yes or no answer. Make sure to focus on open ended questions which will allow the candidate to shine.
There is also such a thing as pointless questions. Avoid falling into the trap of asking the kinds of questions that give you meaningless answers. For example, asking a question such as, Do you enjoy coming to work? will probably not lead to a very satisfying answer.
Read Also: What Should Females Wear To A Job Interview
Benefits Of Structured Interviews
Structured interviews provide a number of advantages over unstructured ones, including:
- Enhanced objectivity and equal opportunity. By asking the same questions and assessing responses according to the same job-relevant criteria, candidates have an equal opportunity to demonstrate their qualifications and to be assessed fairly. In addition, the use of an interview board rather than one individual assessor increases objectivity since consensus on a final evaluation must be reached.
- Accuracy and prediction. Since questions are linked to job-related competencies, a candidate’s responses are more likely to predict their on-the-job performance. Research has shown that structured interviews are up to twice as effective at predicting job performance as unstructured ones1–2.
- Greater legal defensibility. When structured interviews are developed and administered according to professional guidelines, they are more likely to be legally defensible. To date, the following three components have been found to be most closely scrutinized by the courts when using an interview:
- The consistency of applying the interview across applicants
- The job-relatedness of the interview questions and
- The extent to which the interview process was designed to be objective.
Given the enhanced accuracy, consistency, and procedural rigour of a structured interview relative to a more informal process, the gathered information is more likely to comply with the requirements of relevant legislation.
How Much Do You Get Paid For A Working Interview
Yes and no. From an employer’s perspective, you are not required to pay the “hourly” rate for the job, but the minimum wage rate is the foundation hourly rate at which you must compensate employees for each hour performed during the interview. You can send the individual a check at the conclusion of the interview, and you are unlikely to be required to withhold taxes.
Don’t Miss: Interview Attire Womens
How To Conduct An Interview: A Step
If you’ve ever seen a great interviewer in action, you may have the impression that it’s easier than it really is. Don’t let that mistaken assumption leave you unprepared! It can be very difficult to ask the right questions in the right way so that you get the answers you need to evaluate a candidate. If you want to make sure you’re ready, this guide will explain how to conduct an interview.
Study Up On The Candidate Before The Interview
This is the last but most crucial step to preparing for an interview. Plan to spend at least half an hour reviewing the candidate in advance.
You only have a limited window to get to know each candidate. You dont want to spend too much of the interview making them repeat whats on their resume. So its wise to review the candidate’s information in advance. Get to know their job history, check out their LinkedIn profile, review their assessment results, and review any other materials they may have provided before the interview.
If there are any gaps or confusing points in their resume, you can add them to your list of questions to ask the candidate.
Also Check: Best Interview Attire For A Woman
What To Expect At A Working Interview
There are various interviewing methods employers use to find the right candidate for their position. They may range from the traditional sit-down interview to something that looks more like a day of work. As a candidate, it’s important to be aware of the type of interview you’re agreeing to so you know how to prepare. In this article, we specifically address what a working interview is and how to succeed in one.
Section : After The Interview
After the interview, the board is ready to arrive at ratings on the job qualifications for each applicant. To accomplish this task, board members will need their completed Interview Note-taking Bookletand theInterview Assessment Booklet, which include the rating scheme in relation to the qualifications assessed .
The results obtained from interviews should be carefully evaluated in order to accurately assess the qualifications required and to minimize personal bias. This evaluation involves a sequence of key steps beginning with individual assessments by members of the interview board, followed by an assessment based on a group consensus. The integration of the interview results, along with other obtained information concludes the appointment process. In addition, the interview board may be involved in informal discussion or in providing feedback to the applicant. In this section, guidance is offered on each of these key components.
You May Like: Preparing For System Design Interview
Consider The Style And Number Of Interviewers
Interviews can happen via video, over the phone, or in person, so consider what style of interview is best and plan accordingly. You can also determine how many people you need to hold an interview, like a panel of colleagues for a prominent role or multiple rounds of interviews for a high-level position. Involving other relevant leaders in the interview process can also be useful to get different perspectives on the candidates experience and abilities.
Poor Hygiene And Personal Appearance
It should go without saying that you should always have good hygiene in a professional environment. No employee wants a smelly co-worker, and recruiters feel the same. According to a 2017 Recruiter Nation report, more than half of recruiters would disqualify a job candidate because of bad hygiene.
Make sure you are clean, polished-looking, and dressed appropriately for the position you are applying for. If you are unsure, err on the side of professional dress more than casual.
Don’t Miss: Questions To Ask A Cfo During An Interview
Benefits Of The Working Interview
During the working interview, you can assess the candidate’s actual skill level instead of simply reading about it or going by their professional recommendations. Some people can talk a good game but reveal their weaknesses after you hire them. A working interview leaves the job candidate with no place to hide.
You can also get a real sense of the person’s personality and ability to work with others during an actual work situation. The candidate will be able to do their own assessment of the team and the required duties as well. This warts and all approach benefits everyone involved.
Of course, this method isn’t foolproof, but you have a better chance of determining a person’s suitability for the position if you watch them work. In addition, you weed out people who do not have the skill set you need. In the dental industry, unskilled employees can be dangerous to patients, so employment risks are certainly higher than in other professions.
Instead To Be Legal And Protected Once Someone Starts Working For You You Should Do All Of The Following:
- Pay them no less than minimum wage.
- Withhold payroll taxes.
- Get a background check and verify their eligibility to work in the US.
- Cover the employee for Workers Compensation, and notify your carrier to ensure coverage.
- Ensure the employee has completed HIPAA training.
- Provide a copy of your Employee Handbook and have them sign it. The protections in it apply only to those who receive a copy and have acknowledged the policies inside.
Also Check: Questions To Ask A Cfo In An Interview
What Is An Exit Interview
The purpose of exit interview strategy is to create a purposeful conversation with the employee to better understand their reasons for leaving your company. Was it the low salary? Were they offered a more flexible job somewhere else? Or, in a worst-case scenario, did a managers poor leadership style make the employee feel as though there was no other choice? Though conducting an exit interview may reveal flaws in your managers, organizations should choose to think of this discourse as constructive. Its best to learn the key issues and correct the course rather than waking up to five to ten employees resignation letters in your managers inboxes.
Give The Candidate A Chance To Ask Questions
Hopefully youve been leaving space for questions throughout the interview, but it helps to offer some structured time at the end as the interviewee collects their thoughts. Transition the candidate into this phase of the interview by saying, OK, I think Ive gotten everything I need to know at this stage, thank you. Is there anything more you would like me to know? Do you have any questions?
Keep in mind: You dont have to launch into long explanations for every question they ask. You may not even know the answer if the question is highly technical, and its fine to say so. Just make it a point that you will get back to them with an answerand be sure you follow up!
Read Also: Design Interview Preparation
What Is A Working Interview And How To Outperform In One
Whats a working interview? First, lets talk about what comes to mind when we hear the word interview. Most of us still picture ourselves sitting opposite a few gentlemen. In todays dynamic business world, though, employers hiring process is diverse and unconventional.
Employers use numerous interviewing methods to find the ideal candidate. Even the questions asked in interviews have taken a step away from the traditional. Another interviewing technique that has opted out of tradition is the concept of a working interview.
HR professionals have dubbed this method as highly pragmatic and incredibly beneficial to both the employer and the candidate. Here we have discussed everything about a working interview: