Thursday, June 23, 2022

Are Exit Interviews A Good Idea

Don't Miss

Do You Feel Your Job Description Changed Since You Were Hired How

How to Handle the Exit Interview

The way we work is constantly in flux, so it should come as no surprise if an employee indicates that his job changed while he worked at your company. Take the information this employee gives and use it to update the job description before starting the hiring process. That way, you can be sure you are looking for the right skills to fill the vacant position.

Where Should An Employee Exit Interview Occur

An exit interview should occur on neutral ground, like in a separate meeting room. A one-on-one conversation with a colleague from the HR department should create a good atmosphere in which the employee can open up without feeling like they are being interrogated. Use a questionnaire to guide the discussion so that you can be sure to cover all the topics that you feel are relevant. Take notes on the employees answers.

Why Are You Leaving Your Position Or What Led You To The Decision To Leave

Your employer may ask this question to find out if you are leaving because you have been offered a better opportunity or for personal reasons. Try to maintain a balance between honesty and politeness when answering this question. If applicable, mention the skills or experience youre hoping to get from your next job.

Example:I have really enjoyed working here, and I have learned a lot over the course of my employment. However, I feel like I have accomplished all I can in this role and need something different. While I have learned much at this job and honed my skills and experience, I feel it is time to go in a different direction. I have gained invaluable experience for the future, and I feel the time is right to expand my experience and strengthen my abilities.

Read more: How To Explain Your Reasons for Leaving a Job

Don’t Miss: Questions To Ask A Cfo During An Interview

What Would You Change About Your Job

The answer to this question can help you see whether or not you need to change this particular position before you hire someone else. If the job itself caused the employee to leave, you may be hiring someone into a volatile position. Make the position better and you avoid high turnover in the future.

How To Conduct An Employee Exit Interview

Sample Exit Interview format Luxury Free 6 Exit Interview ...

TL DR: Exit interviews are among the most important offboarding tools â especially when paired with employee exit surveys. Effective exit interviews are well structured and allow you to gather unique insights into the employee experience and leverage that data to improve the work environment and increase retention.

Recommended Reading: Best Interview Attire For A Woman

You’ll Burn Bridges If You Aren’t Respectful

As with all feedback, it’s important to proceed with caution, and be balanced and fair, Traci Wilk, senior vice president of people at The Learning Experience, tells CNBC Make It.

If you don’t think you can find constructive words and phrases to describe your time with the company, she suggests telling the interviewer you’d like to postpone the interview. This should provide enough time and distance to craft and refine your narrative.

“This is likely not to be the final connection with your employer and your company’s leadership, so it’s an opportune time to ensure you’re leaving on a good note and not burning any bridges,” explains Wilk, who previously worked as an HR executive at Starbucks for seven years.

“Even if you’re leaving an unpleasant work situation, speaking too harshly could have a long-term impact,” she adds.

If You Still Feel Compelled To Do An Exit Interview

I hate offering these options because you really should decline. However, if the desire to be “nice” has overwhelmed you and you feel compelled to participate in this useless and potentially harmful exercise, minimize your risk with these options:

  • Ask your interviewer to email you their exit interview form because you are so incredibly busy tying up loose ends. Say that you’ll return it to them with your written answers.
  • Request to schedule the exit interview via phone for a date after you leave. You may or may not get around to returning that call, however, because your new job will have you so busy. You’ll also have a more detached, balanced perspective then.
  • Give in and attend the exit interview, but offer vague platitudes instead of telling the truth. For example,
  • I’m not sure. I haven’t given much thought much to that.
  • This role isn’t the best fit for me right now.
  • I just feel like my work here at this company is done.
  • I wanted to explore other opportunities.
  • I don’t feel comfortable divulging my new pay rate. That’s private information.

Be calm and professional in your demeanor and refuse to get sucked into negativity. Imagine the people you’re talking aboutexecutives, coworkers, and supervisorssitting there listening to your feedback.

Don’t Miss: Design Interview Preparation

How To Conduct An Exit Interview: Questions To Ask And Tips

Do you know how to conduct an exit interview that will help you better understand what you could have done to keep a departing employee?

Really effective exit interviews can give you that insight. They can teach you ways to repeat good experiences and avoid bad ones .

For employees, exit interviews are one of the last deep conversational interactions they have with your company. It should be their chance to give a review of their experience, an opportunity that affirms the contributions theyve made to your organization.

When both parties focus on these learning and knowledge-sharing goals, exit interviews can help working relationships end on a good note. Many times the feedback employees provide is positive, and when its not, it gives you valuable insight on how to fix it for your existing employees.

When To Use This Playbook

“Survivor 41” Fifteenth Castaway Exit Interview

Whenever an employee decides to leave the business, use this playbook to gather information about their experience working at the company.

As with employee exit surveys, which we recommend running before the exit interview, this playbook should be an ongoing initiative in your company. The purpose is to continuously analyze the data surfaced in employee exit interviews , discussing and implementing actions for organizational improvement.

Also Check: Mailscoop Io

Good Tools For Conducting Exit Interview Surveys

While some traditionalists prefer to use a word doc for exit interview surveys, todays technology has a number of good options for streaming your exit interview process.

Here are a few of our favorites:

  • Typeform: Typeform is an interactive survey tool that you can use to streamline your exit interviews. You can use conditional questions, and even customize surveys to match your brand. We like typeform because of its modern feel and functionality.
  • SurveyMonkey: SurveyMonkey is a popular, free survey tool that can be used to conduct exit interview surveys. We recommend it as a step-up from using word docs.
  • Checkster: Checkster is an enterprise HR survey tool. Checkster can be used by HR teams to streamline, standardize, and better leverage your exit surveys. Checkster offers detailed analytics into usage, and time spent by your former employee while completing their exit survey, as well as options for referrals.

Most Organizations Are Making A Costly Mistake

In-person exit interviews, in particular, are essentially worthless. Any exiting employee will have the tact to sanitize the truth. Distrust of HR, even in upstanding organizations, makes gleaning any information of even remote value next to impossible. Go ahead, tell your now ex-employee that he or she is free to speak honestly. Will the individual trust the HR department or expect it to focus more on protecting the company from legal ramifications first and foremost? In the worst-case scenario, will the person fear that HR personnel could share private details with managers, third-party recruiters even the ex-employees new employer?

Legitimacy and credibility aside, first-party exit interviews rarely receive the time and effort thats necessary to produce measurable data or meaningful insights. Youre left with a disorganized pile of gossip fuel and little else.

Its not necessarily an easy decision to trust a third-party vendor to handle your exit interviews. It is, on the other hand, a sound financial decision. Each employee you have to replace is costing you tens of thousands of dollars if not more. Typical organizations accept this as immutable truth. Progressive organizations do something about it namely, they consult turnover experts for an alternative to their best idea of best practices.

Read Also: What To Wear For An Interview Women

Now: The 15 Exit Interview Questions

Reasons for Leaving

  • Why did you begin looking for another job?
  • If you could change anything about the organization, what would you choose?
  • Did you voice your concerns to anyone else at the company?
  • Experience

  • Did you think your work goals and responsibilities were clear?
  • Did you feel you had all the resources you needed to do your best work here?
  • What did you think of the way you were managed?
  • Did you receive frequent, constructive feedback from your manager and peers?
  • What benefits or programs did you feel were missing from the organization?
  • How would you describe the culture of our company?
  • What did you appreciate most about working here?
  • Is there anything we could have done to make you want to stay?
  • Looking Ahead

    Why Are You Leaving

    25 Sample Exit Interview forms in 2020

    Some may see these first two questions as the same, but theyre actually very different. Your employee may have started looking to switch jobs for one reason. But she may have made the final decision for a host of other reasons.

    These two questions help you determine everything that prompted her to leavefrom initial dissatisfaction to the final straw that broke the camels back.

    Read Also: Top 10 Behavioral Questions

    Saying Goodbye: How To Conduct Effective Exit Interviews

    Exit interviews aren’t the time-wasting formality that some departing employees might think they are, new research finds.

    The majority of human resources managers listen carefully to what’s said during interviews with exiting workers, with more than 60 percent saying their organization takes action on the feedback given by employees on their way out, according to a study from the staffing firm OfficeTeam.

    Specifically, 29 percent of those who act on the newly gleaned information update job descriptions, 24 percent address comments about management, 22 percent make changes to the work environment, and 19 percent review employee salaries.

    The ability to obtain candid feedback is sometimes the only silver lining to losing an employee, said Brandi Britton, a district president for OfficeTeam.

    “Departing workers can provide valuable insights that current staff may be reluctant to share,” Britton said in a statement. “Although not every criticism will be worth responding to, the most crucial issues should be addressed immediately to help keep existing team members happy and loyal.”

    To help employers, OfficeTeam offers several tips for conducting effective exit interviews:

    The study was based on surveys of more than 300 HR managers at U.S. companies with 20 or more employees.

    Why Do Companies Conduct Exit Interviews

    Companies conduct exit interviews so to hear an employees opinions about their job, supervisor, organization and more. An exit interview is a conversation between you and your employerlikely a human resources representative. This is an opportunity to discuss job satisfaction or offer feedback on policy and direction.

    Related: How to Find a New Job While Employed

    Also Check: Questions To Ask Cfo In Interview

    Exit Interview Questions For Managers / Leaders

    Losing company leaders and managers can be a tough pill to swallow. These employees can be more difficult to replace. Learning why and preventing other leaders from leaving your company is key for conducting an exit interview with these roles.

    Here are some effective questions to ask managers and leaders in exit interviews.

    • What made you decide to look for a new role?
    • Were there any obstacles that made your job here especially challenging?
    • What were the key factors leading you to look for a role at another company?
    • What factors made you choose your new company over their competitors?
    • Could we have done anything to have prevented you from seeking a new role?
    • Did we provide you with all of the resources you needed to succeed? If not, then what could we have done better?
    • How do our salary and benefits compare to your new company? Were salary and benefits an important factor in your decision?
    • What could we have done to prevent you from switching companies?
    • What are three areas you think our company must improve in to prevent people in your role from migrating to other companies?
    • How could our company change to get you to return in the future?
    • Do you feel our company/product/services are heading in the right direction to stay innovative and competitive with the market? If no, then why?

    What Skills And Qualifications Do You Think We Need To Look For In Your Replacement

    Exit Interview

    Who has better insight into what it takes to do your job well than you? Spoiler alert: nobody. You were the one who got the work done day in and day out. And, chances are, you did it well. So, your employer wants to know what qualities they should keep their eyes out for when replacing you.

    Perhaps your original job description emphasized that you needed to be great with database management. But, once you were there, you realized that database was rarely even touched by anyone in your office. It was an obsolete job duty that they kept pasting over from description to description. Instead, you think that looking for someone with strong organizational and multi-tasking skills is a way more important facet to emphasize. Trust me, your employer will appreciate this information.

    An exit interview is really nothing to stress over. Think of it as your chance to have a valuable and honest discussion about the ins and outs of the position youre leaving. And, if you do start to feel stressed, just ask yourself whats the worst that can happen. After all, they cant fire you.

    You May Like: Questions To Ask A Cfo

    How Would You Improve Employee Morale

    Just hours ago, this employee was in the thick of things. He was dealing with company culture and being influenced by others morale first-hand. Living through that on a day-to-day basis gives him unique insight into how that morale and culture can be improved. This is the time to find out what he thinks.

    Keep A Positive Attitude

    If you come across as overly critical and cynical, your employer might misread your intentions and regard you as overly bitter. If you care about the company and the people there, and you do feel like your feedback can make a difference, do not refrain from providing it.

    However, make sure that you provide fact-based comments. You can also consider highlighting the things that you did like about the job. It can provide insights into the things that are actually working, as well as the factors that contribute to a positive employee experience.

    Also Check: What Should Females Wear To A Job Interview

    Would You Consider Staying On

    Your employer might ask this question to discover whether additions to the job, such as benefits or additional training, might make it more attractive. Be honest in your response and consider whether you would truly want to stay and what factors might affect your decision.

    Example:I have worked here for a long time, and this company has provided me with valuable skills and learning opportunities. I have enjoyed working here, but I feel that my expertise and career goals would be highly prioritized at my new position. However, if I received the right offer, I would strongly consider returning.

    What Was Your Relationship With Your Manager Like

    FREE 5+ Exit Interview Forms in PDF

    Your working relationship with your boss was probably the most influential in your daily work life, so your company wants to know the good, bad, and the ugly. What did your supervisor do well? How did you feel about his or her management style overall?

    Be prepared to also provide some suggestions for ways he or she can improve. It might seem counterintuitive to say anything negative about your supervisorespecially when the dont ever complain about your boss rule has been ingrained in your memory for years. But its necessary feedback.

    Again, just remember that you dont want to go off the rails and begin berating your boss. After all, much of your criticism will likely be relayed back to this person. So, when in doubt, keep it constructive.

    Recommended Reading: Preparing For System Design Interview

    Speak From Prepared Notes

    If you’re concerned about forgetting to mention important items or getting emotional about a particular part of your job, consider making a list of talking points and bring it with you to the interview. This way you can cover the topics you want to discuss even if you have to stop and restart to answer questions from an interviewer.

    How To Use Exit Interviews To Reduce Employee Turnover

    Exit interviews arent funerals. They dont have to be tearful or awkward situations. Instead, they can be a source of incredibly valuable information for your company, if done the right way.

    For example, if employees are leaving for other work, they may have insights about how to reduce turnover. If theyre departing involuntarily, the interview can be used for damage control. Interviewing an employee whos leaving your company should be a learning experience for everyone involved.

    It doesnt have to be awkward

    In small- and mid-size companies, an exit interview can be uncomfortable, given the intimacy between management and employees. People are guarded, particularly if theyre leaving the organization, says Lori Johnson, a team lead for ADP TotalSource, Culver City, California, an HR outsourcing firm.

    Many departing employees dont want to alienate their former employers, so they avoid honest criticism in their final interviews. Instead of telling you the operations manager is a bully, they come up with inoffensive reasons for their departure: more money, better benefits or more responsibility.

    By changing the focus of the last interview, an employer can learn about the company brand from their employees perspective. Robert Greene, CEO of Reward Systems, a management consulting firm, says companies should ask why they started looking for another job.

    That will get them to tell you the truth, he says. Youll see where youre coming up short.

    Also Check: Interview With Cfo

    More articles

    Popular Articles