How To Evaluate Interview Candidates

Ask About Their Short

During the interview, ask about any previous roles they had that lasted less than two years. If a candidate has multiple short-term roles, it may indicate some problems.

Ask them why they left these roles. If they talk about problems they had that will be the same with the position they’re interviewing for, they may not be the best fit for the job.

For example, if they didn’t like working early in the morning and you’re only offering an early morning shift, they may not want to continue pursuing the position.

Observe How The Candidate Behaves Outside The Interview Room

One of the reasons we do interviews is to get to know candidates and determine if theyll be a positive addition to the team. Its important to find out if someone is a jerk before its too late.

But candidates are on their best behavior during job interviews so it can be hard to see true colors. Try observing how they interact with people who arent interviewing them. Do they exchange pleasantries with the office manager who greets them? Do they treat others around your office the same way they treat you? Try to figure out if the personality they bring to the interview is authentic or just for show.

Keep All Comments In One Place

Exchanging emails to share feedback may result in clogged inboxes and miscommunication Instead, use a shared document or a platform that all team members can access at any time. And ask team members to write down their feedback right after the interviews, when the conversation is still fresh in their minds.

Read Also: What Questions Do You Ask In An Interview

Recommended Reading: Where Can I Watch The Oprah Interview With Prince Harry

How Do I Reduce Bias When Interviewing Candidates

Bias is human, but it still sucks, and its no excuse for running a biased interview process. Heres a quick checklist to make sure you address some of the most common sources of bias in interviews:

• Give every candidate the same information and the same opportunity to prepare.
• Stick to a structured interview focused on job related-skills, asking each candidate the same set of questions.
• Keep an open mind during the interviewduring the interview, your role is to collect information. Only afterward should you assess the candidate.
• Acknowledge your biases ! Bringing awareness to your own biases can help you view candidates more objectively.
• Include more than one person in your interview and, ideally, people who are different from you. That allows the candidate to meet more people but also provides another perspective when assessing the candidate.
• Avoid inadvertently asking discriminatory questions .

Keep in mind that how and where you market your job opening and how you choose who to invite to interviews can often be an even more significant source of bias, and there is much you can and should do to address bias in sourcing and selection.

Evaluating Candidates After An Interview

Interviewingand choosing candidateswas never easy. Now, with remote hiring on the rise, its more difficult than ever. But whether youve conducted a virtual interview or an in-person assessment, the same basic challenges apply.

Choosing the right candidate for an open position is a lot like putting a puzzle together.

Even with all the right pieces in front of you, it can still be extremely difficult to decide between multiple candidates, especially since the final batch of candidates are all likely to be highly qualified.

If youre lucky enough to have entered the final stages of your hiring process with more than one qualified candidate, how do you decide on a final hire? For most companies, the answer to this question takes the form of a post-interview evaluation.

Its a tricky decision and one that can hold grave consequences if the wrong choice is made after all, conducting a hiring effort requires a huge amount of resources, and if it all falls through in the end, your company could lose out on weeks or even months of productivity.

In this article we cover why the post-interview evaluation is so important and how any company can conduct a proper post-interview evaluation to uncover the perfect candidate.

Recommended Reading: How To Prepare For Medical Assistant Interview

How To Evaluate A Company At Your Interview

Interviews are stressful. You spend hours over your initial application, research and prepare for days, and then generally have less than an hour to try and prove that youre the perfect person for the role. And because youre so focussed on impressing your interviewer and being your best self, it can be easy to forget that, actually, their opinions arent the only important ones.

Start forming your impression of the company as soon as you arrive. After all, the reception area is the first place that any visiting clients will see, so it should tell you a lot about how the company chooses to present itself. The set-up will vary according to the size of company a start-up or small company with 5 employers might not have a lobby at all but do you like what you see when you walk in? And can you imagine welcoming someone there yourself?

How to Evaluate Your Job Interview Performance Gainor Staffing is a leading staffing agency in the New York City area. Too often scheduling a job interview is where the prep and evaluation time ends for a candidate. Instead of leaving it to chance, consider these evaluation techniques to help you in your next interview.

Take The Hassle Out Of Recruitment

Our dedicated recruitment consultants are experts at finding the perfect new employee for your company. Rather than trying to navigate the recruitment process on your own, we can provide professional assistance to make the journey smoother and quicker. Get in touch with us today to find out how we can help.

Read Also: How To Make A Portfolio For A Job Interview

Why Interview Evaluation Forms Are Important

Curbing bias:

• Interview evaluation forms can help curb bias by allowing organizations to assess candidates on a predetermined criteria. It leaves little room for implicit bias to make its way into the interview process.

Limiting liability:

• Having a predetermined course for an interview and structured script can help you avoid asking illegal or improper interview questions.

Objective comparisons

• One of the best benefits of using interview evaluation forms is that they give a clear comparison between candidates. It allows you to quickly ascertain the stand out candidate and show others why said candidate is the clear choice.

Please Give An Example Of A Project That You Owned And What The Process Was Like From Start To Finish

Asking for specific examples of projects a candidate has been responsible for offers insight into the level of responsibility an applicant has taken on in the past, experience and skills they may have learned along the way, and the executive function skills needed to accomplish the assignment.

It may be helpful to ask follow-up questions about what they found most satisfying or challenging about the work that they completed or how they overcame any obstacles that they outlined in their answer.

Answer example:

I was responsible for revising the landing page for the website at my last job. Our objective was to streamline the information and improve the copy, functionality, and design. I came up with some rough drafts, worked closely with the writers and designers on the marketing team to improve on those ideas, and then used A/B testing to determine which was more popular based on bounce rate and sign-ups. It was a big job with a lot of moving pieces but we saw a 25% increase in sign ups once the new page went live and it was interesting to work with teams in other departments.

Recommended Reading: What To Say In A Customer Service Interview

How To Evaluate An Interview

How you can Evaluate Your Work Interview Performance. Have you ever just completed the interview? Perhaps you have had several interviews lately, but to date, no firm job offers. We all know that awaiting a.

Not receiving any luck to date inside your job search? Maybe its time for you to consider using a different tack. At Individuals with Energy, weve placed candidates in fantastic new roles over the United kingdom and round the world. To discover the way we might help, please send a duplicate of the CV to co. united kingdom and our consultants come in touch.

Video advice: Hiring Process Evaluating Candidates

With high application levels for most jobs, employers will only be looking for the very best candidates to take forward. How you handle questions during an interview comes back to how well you prepared for the interview. If you have done your research, you should be able to answer the majority of questions quite comfortably. However, in an attempt to identify the strongest candidate, an employer will sometimes throw in a question from left field to get you make you think on your feet.

Top 5 Questions To Assess Job Candidates Past Performance

Here is our list of the best questions to ask to assess past performance:

So, there you go. Get answers to these questions and check back whether our pointers are helping you assess and identify the best candidates for the job.

Read Also: How To Prepare For Amazon Interview In A Week

Check Candidates’ Social Media

Some employers may choose to look at the social media profiles of their candidates. Consider researching candidates’ social media profiles to get a comprehensive sense of their formative influences and personality. Examining a candidate’s priorities and lifestyle choices can sometimes provide insight into their professional behaviour. For example, if a candidate posts pictures of volunteer work outside of their core professional domain, they may possess a strong sense of motivation and may be able to work well with groups of diverse professionals.

Why Is Interview Feedback Important

Interview feedback is important for several reasons. Here are a few ways you and your employer can benefit from effective interview feedback:

• Helps interviewers organize their thoughts. After interviewing a candidate, interviewers need time to think more about a candidate and their employable qualities. Writing interview feedback allows interviewers to document everything they can remember, including first impressions or unique answers.

• Assists team members in making good hiring decisions. When hiring teams have a well-written document about a candidate interview, they can use it to form important opinions that they wouldn’t be able to by just hearing about it. This is also important for hiring teams who have to decide between multiple candidates as the document gives them something to refer to, regardless of how much time has passed since the interview.

• Provides candidates with valuable information about their professional attributes. You can use the interview feedback document you created to communicate your reasoning for hiring or dismissing a candidate. For candidates who didn’t get the job, you can send them the document in a candidate dismissal email or provide them with a few positive comments they received to show them they have impressive communication skills, enthusiasm or technical knowledge.

Related:Giving and Receiving Feedback: Definitions and Examples

Read Also: What Is A Video Interview

How To Prepare For The Job Interview

The interview team was selected at your earlier recruiting planning meeting, so the interviewers have had time to prepare. You will want to use the list of qualities, skills, knowledge, and experience you developed for the resume screening process.

Use this list to make sure each interviewer understands their role in the candidate assessment. Review each interviewers questions, too, to make sure the interview questions selected will obtain the needed information.

Why Is Previous Job Performance Assessment Important

Of course, there is a school of thought that may ask out loud, why is previous job performance important?

After all, if the employee was a high performer, any organization will ensure that the employee is retained, motivated and provided the best opportunities to continue performing.

And if that is how it is so, then why will a high performer want to leave the organization?

If the reason is compensation, then is that the only reason why we should be hiring the candidate because anyways, tomorrow there will be someone else offering higher and there will be no way to retain such people.

Thus, isnt it counterintuitive to try to dig into past performance and run the risk of making a wrong judgement?

Recommended Reading: How To Clear Amazon Interview

Tell Me About Yourself

Although this is a common interview question that candidates are likely to prepare for in advance, its open-ended format allows for a wide range of response types. Its also a great way to transition from introductory small talk to official interview mode.

How a candidate approaches the answer can offer another angle of insight: Do they launch right into an elevator speech about their personal or professional life? Do they use the question as an opportunity to explain how their education or work history supports the position theyre hoping to fill? Do they have a clear career path in mind and would this role help fulfill those goals?

Theres no wrong answer but the applicants response and how that response is delivered can tell you a lot about a candidate.

Answer example:

Sure! For the past three years, Ive been working as a social media specialist for a mid-sized marketing agency, where I create, schedule, and manage content for between 5 and 10 clients at a time. I really enjoy the work Im creative, organized, I love meeting deadlines, and I find the analytics reports fascinating, so its a good fit for my personality! Its been great but Id prefer the opportunity to focus my efforts on building a strong brand identity and online community for one company like yours.

Move the right people forward faster

Create A Great Job Description

Create a job description listing the essential skills and experience.

If you want to hire the perfect person for a position, you need to have a really good description of the position. Don’t get caught up with lots of bullet points, like “Office Experience,” and “Computer Skills.”

A good description shouldn’t over-describe. It should focus on what is absolutely necessary for someone to be successful in the position, and describe what success looks like over specific periods of time typically 30, 90, 180 days, and 1 year.

Use the job description as a roadmap for creating questions.

For example, if you’ve determined that customer service skills are essential, you’ll want to create questions related directly to that. How do they define customer service? What is the best customer service experience they’ve ever had? Review all your essentials in the description and build questions directly related to them.

Write out your questions beforehand.

You might think you can remember all of your interview questions, but the reality is that the greatest weakness of most interviewers is exposed when they try flying blind. Write down your questions, and be sure to give yourself enough blank space to jot down notes.

Jot down notes during the interview.

Get specific details and come back to them.

Make sure you’re on the same page with salary expectations.

Ask detailed questions about roles that lasted less than two years.

Read Also: Case Study Interview Questions For Business Analyst

Most Popular Interview Questions And Answers

Although its tempting to want to curate a list of unique and creative questions, popular interview questions are popular for a reason and the answers can reveal a lot about a candidates personality or background. We surveyed hiring professionals to find out which popular interview questions are their favorites.

Example: Content Writer Position

Lets look at the complete list of requirements for the role of Content Writer.

These exclude experience and education, which can vary considerably depending on the role and are elements you can evaluate directly from the job application phase.

Must-have skills

Some companies may have other or additional requirements, but this list covers the most important qualities.

Hard skills

• Problem-solving skills

The first three skills can be classified as hard, tangible skills and theyre the absolute minimum candidates should possess to be considered qualified for the job. Thats why you can evaluate them via an assessment or a work sample

You can ask content writing candidates to submit their answers to an editing exercise. For other roles, it might be a simulation or a presentation .

Assessments will give you a strong measuring stick to evaluate candidates: you can shorten your candidate pool to ensure that only the best candidates make it to the interview phase.

There, you can start evaluating the soft skills, along with culture fit, attitude, and other intangibles that arent as easily measured. Some skills can also be evaluated during initial screening calls.

Don’t Miss: How To Record An Interview On Iphone